RefBan

Referral Banners

Monday, April 25, 2011

Why Julian Assange Can't Let Go of His Secrets

By John Cook

Why Julian Assange Can't Let Go of His Secrets

Why Julian Assange Can't Let Go of His SecretsWikileaks founder Julian Assange's reputation as a fighter for transparency and destroyer of secrets ought to be thoroughly demolished by today's spectacle of the New York Times literally forcing him to give up the Guantanamo Bay files he'd been hoarding for months.

Assange has been sitting on the 700-plus Gitmo detainee files since at least May of last year, when accused Wikileaker Bradley Manning confessed in a chat session to passing them to Wikileaks along with a plethora of classified military reports and diplomatic cables. They were the final sizable arrow in Assange's anti-government quiver, and for months we've been waiting, and waiting, and waiting for their inevitable release. But Assange kept holding back.

They were published last night, at long last, only because the New York Times finagled its own copy—presumably from Wikileaks defector Daniel Domscheit-Berg—and shared it with NPR and the Guardian. Wikileaks, which had been working with the Washington Post and other papers on the Gitmo papers but was still keeping the information embargoed, scrambled to get its own version up.

Why Julian Assange Can't Let Go of His SecretsIf a newspaper had scored a trove of Gitmo papers and kept them secret for a year, the delay would cause a minor scandal—as the New York Times' decision to hold its blockbuster illegal surveillance story did. The fact that Wikileaks represents itself not as a newspaper but as a force for transparency and an anti-secrecy organization makes it all the more galling that Assange had to be prodded by the hidebound Times—which had no incentive to dawdle—into actually, you know, revealing his secrets.

And those secrets remain largely unrevealed! Wikileaks' own headline—"The Guantanamo Files: 779 classified prisoner dossiers revealed from the world's most notorious prison"—is a lie. ‎Wikileaks has only teased 80 of the files it claims to have, promising that the rest "will be released daily over the coming month." It made a similar promise with the 250,000 classified diplomatic cables that it never actually released—so far, 7,579, or 3% of the total, have been released. The rest remain, for all intents and purposes, classified. When it comes to the Gitmo files and the cables, Assange is an agent of secrecy, not its enemy.

Why the strip-tease act? Assange has claimed in the past that simply dumping secret data on the web is a strategy for making sure that newspapers ignore it, and that in order to honor his sources' desires for maximum impact, he needs to work with "news partners" and drag things out a bit. He's also cited "harm-minimization"—the need to review each document to make sure informants and such aren't named before publication. But if his sources' wishes are to be honored—and to be clear, Manning has for the past year been essentially Assange's only source—then Assange had better speed things up. In chats with hacker Adrian Lamo before he was arrested, Manning made clear that he took the risk of leaking his mother lode to Assange because he wanted it all—not just 3%—made public: "Hillary Clinton and several thousand diplomats around the world are going to have a heart attack when they wake up one morning and find an entire repository of classified foreign policy is available, in searchable format, to the public.... [It will be] worldwide anarchy in CSV format.... Beautiful, and horrifying."

If Assange were acting in Manning's interest, he would have gone for "worldwide anarchy" and thrown everything up as soon as he could. But he took another tack, one that involved partnering with high-profile news outlets, releasing Manning's data in dribs and drabs while continuously hinting at the next blockbuster disclosure, and becoming a global celebrity in the process. While Manning sits in a prison cell.

More recently, Assange has come to view the unpublished bits of Manning's cache as, literally, insurance. That's what he called the 1.4 gigabyte encrypted file he posted to Wikileaks last year, just a month before allegations of rape surfaced against him in Sweden. The clear implication was that if anything happens to him—like, say, extradition to Sweden to face the aforementioned charges—a password would be distributed and the file made public. With each new disclosure, that insurance file affords him less and less leverage, which explains his reluctance to follow Manning's wishes and actually disclose information.

Why Julian Assange Can't Let Go of His SecretsAnd with the Gitmo files—assuming he actually carries through on his promise to release the remaining ones—Assange has essentially blown his wad. The only outstanding bits he has from Manning are videotape of a 2009 airstrike in Granai, Afghanistan by U.S. gunships that killed roughly 100 civilians and 15,000 "war logs" from Afghanistan that he held back from release last year for further redaction. In his chats with Lamo, Manning described the Afghanistan video as "not nearly as damning" as the other video he sent to Wikileaks, footage of two Reuters journalists being killed by U.S. helicopters in Baghdad. And it's unclear what the remaining war logs contain, but any news in them has almost certainly been reported by the New York Times and the Guardian, which also had access to the full unredacted cache. Aside from those Manning leftovers, Assange is also said to have the hard-drive of a Bank of America executive from 2006, but the data on it is "not self-explanatory and...he personally was unable to make much sense of it," according to Reuters.

In other words, the Gitmo files could be Assange's last hurrah. Wikileaks' encrypted submission has been broken for more than a year now, which means no new juicy tidbits have been coming in. And without the threat of more earth-shattering disclosures down the road, will anyone really care whether Assange is extradited to Sweden, or gets convicted of rape, or goes to jail? Not really. Which is why he's publishing the Gitmo files under duress.

[Photo of Assange, top, via AP. Photo of Domscheit-Berg and Assange, bottom, via Getty Images]

Number of comments
  • Share this:

The Afternoon Scoop - Exclusive: Mubarak's Library Cash Stash

To view The Afternoon Scoop online, click here:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/htmlprev?t=BNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF&RAF_TRACK=&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com

*************************************************************************
The Daily Beast - The Afternoon Scoop - April 25, 2011
*************************************************************************

CHEAT SHEET
MUST READS FROM ALL OVER

EXCLUSIVE
1. Mubarak's Library Cash Stash

Prosecutors hunting for the fallen Egyptian leader's money may have
their first big break: a $145 million account, meant for a famous
library, mysteriously bearing Mubarak's name. Philip Shenon reports.

Read it at The Daily Beast:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/dail1
*************************************************************************

RESILIENT
2. Gaddafi Still in 'High Spirits'

Three people were killed in a targeted NATO airstrike on Col. Gaddafi's
Libya compound on Monday - yet the despot is still in "high spirits,"
according to a government spokesman. "He is well, he is healthy," the
official continued. Meanwhile, his son told a state news agency that
NATO was "waging a losing battle because you are backed by traitors and
spies." It's not the first time Gaddafi's compound has been struck, but
NATO has recently been increasing airstrike interventions in Tripoli.
Libyan authorities are reaching out to Russia, China, Italy, Turkey, and
other countries to help implement a ceasefire. The African Union has
been meeting with rebels to discuss a peace plan, but considering their
recent failure to end conflicts in Somalia, Madagascar, and Ivory Coast,
it's not likely that they will be much help. Death tolls continue to
rise and hospitals are packed with injured civilians.

Read it at Reuters:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/dail2
*************************************************************************

Click here for more of the Cheat Sheet at The Daily Beast:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/cs

CONDEMNATION
White House Mulls Syria Sanctions
As regime sends tanks into volatile city.
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/cht3

FINALLY
Couric to Announce She's Leaving CBS
60 Minutes' Scott Pelley her likely successor.
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/cht4

GADGETS
Is This the New iPhone 5?
Imagined by tech blogger Joshua Topolsky.
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/cht5

ANTIQUING
500-Year-Old Book Found in Utah
Passed down to man by great uncle.
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/cht6
*************************************************************************

Sign up for The Yes List, weekly cultural recommendations from The Daily
Beast:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/yeslist

*************************************************************************

For more of The Daily Beast, become a fan on Facebook:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/facebook
and follow us on Twitter: http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/twitter

*************************************************************************
To receive the HTML version of The Afternoon Scoop, click here:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/html?email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com

Forward this email to a friend:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/raf?t=BNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF&RAF_TRACK=&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com

About Us:
http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF/abt

Contact Us: mailto:editorial@thedailybeast.com

To unsubscribe click the link below:
http://ebm.cheetahmail.com/r/webunsub?n=100&t=BNtcmLB7SwhTB8amIUNsjV9opF&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com


Address: 555 West 18th Street | New York, NY 10011

Today in Slate: The Case For Taking the Trump Campaign More Seriously; Plus, the Politics of Parks and Recreation

Slate
 
Briefing News & Politics Arts Life Business & Tech Science Podcasts & Video Blogs
 
 

Today: April 25, 2011

No Joke

No Joke

The case for taking the Trump campaign more seriously.

By Jeff Winkler

READ FULL STORY | More News and Politics

This Waiter Doesn't Need a Tip

This Waiter Doesn't Need a Tip

How restaurants will use tablet computers to replace servers.

By Annie Lowrey

READ FULL STORY | More Business and Tech

It's a Small World After All

It's a Small World After All

A slide show of aerial photography, from pigeon-mounted cameras to Apollo 17 and beyond.

By Elizabeth Weingarten 

READ FULL STORY | More Arts

Stop Calling Drones "Killer Robots." They're Not Robots at All.

Stop Calling Drones "Killer Robots." They're Not Robots at All.

How Can Judges Decide When Threats Against Judges Are Protected by the First Amendment?

How Can Judges Decide When Threats Against Judges Are Protected by the First Amendment?

Jim Shepard Writes Terrific Short Stories About Massive Catastrophes

Jim Shepard Writes Terrific Short Stories About Massive Catastrophes

 
Advertisement
 

Briefing

News & Politics

Arts

Life

Business & Tech

Science

Podcasts & Video

Manage your newsletters on Slate Unsubscribe | Forward to a Friend | Advertising Information

Please do not reply to this message since this is an unmonitored e-mail address.

Ideas on how to make something better? Send an e-mail to slatenewsletter@nl.slate.com.

Copyright 2011 The Slate Group | Privacy Policy
The Slate Group | c/o E-mail Customer Care | 1350 Connecticut Avenue NW Suite 410 | Washington, D.C. 20036

Exclusive: Inside the Taliban Jail Break

The Daily Beast - Welcome Message

If you are on a mobile device or cannot view the images in this message click here : http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb/txt?email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.comto receive the text-only version of this email.

If you cannot view the images in this message, click here : http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb/htmlprev?t=BNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb&RAF_TRACK=&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com.

The Daily Beast

Exclusive: Inside the Taliban Jail Break : http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb/main by Sami Yousafzai and Ron Moreau

In a stunning escape, nearly 500 Taliban fighters fled an Afghanistan prison through an underground tunnel on Monday. Ron Moreau and Sami Yousafzai talk exclusively to two freed men about how they pulled it off, what their next move is - and why they're "more determined than ever" to rejoin the war against America.

Click to read more. : http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb/main

The Daily Beast


Forward this email to a friend : http://e.thedailybeast.com/a/tBNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb/raf?t=BNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb&RAF_TRACK=&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com
| Unsubscribe : http://ebm.cheetahmail.com/r/webunsub?n=100&t=BNtbkiB7SwhTB8amFuNsjV9oUb&email=dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com Copyright © RTST, Inc. All rights reserved. | 555 West 18th Street | New York, NY 10011

Security concerns for the cloud? Overcome them now

Security Product Update
SCCM Users: Is Your Patch Management System Up to Par? | 5 Things to Know About Vulnerability Management
Having trouble viewing this email?View in a browser window
Web Buyer's Guide::Security Product Update
SECURITY WHITE PAPERS AND RESOURCES April 25, 2011
Security Concerns for the Cloud? Overcome Them Now

SCCM Users: Is Your Patch Management System Up to Par?

5 Things to Know About Vulnerability Management

How to Tackle New IT Security Threats

The Security Case for Power Management

How to Deliver Endpoint Security in a Mobile Environment

Sponsored by Sophos

FREE Compliance for Dummies Book from Sophos Get 10 tips to achieve compliance. Request a book today!
Learn more
Sign up for complimentary subscriptions to eWEEK, CIO Insight and Baseline magazines and receive a 360° view of today's technology arena. eWEEK gives you expert products reviews that helps you choose the best technologies. CIO Insight provides a high-level look at technologies and processes. And Baseline takes you to the front lines, with in-depth case studies. Subscribe today!
To avoid any problems with your newsletter delivery, please add newsletters@response.webbuyersguide.com to your addressbook.
You are subscribed to this newsletter with the e-mail address dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com.
If you no longer wish to receive Web Buyer's Guide Security Product Update, unsubscribe here
Copyright © 2011 Ziff Davis Enterprise. All Rights Reserved.
Ziff Davis Enterprise, 28 East 28th Street, New York, NY 10016
Privacy Policy

The CIO's Guide to Optimizing Virtual Desktops

7 Reasons to Deploy a Centralized Virtual Desktop | Get a Constant Connection to Every PC in Your Network
Having trouble viewing this email? View in a browser window
Web Buyer's Guide: Desktops and Notebooks Product Update
DESKTOPS & NOTEBOOKS RESOURCES April 25, 2011
bullet The CIO's Guide to Optimizing Virtual Desktops

bullet 7 Reasons to Deploy a Centralized Virtual Desktop

bullet Get a Constant Connection to Every PC in Your Network

bullet 5 Steps to Getting Started with Virtual Desktops

bullet Desktop Management: How to Streamline a Demanding Deployment

bullet VMware View: An In-depth ROI Analysis

Sponsored by Microsoft

This month's featured article takes a peek at Microsoft's WebMatrix - a Web development tool that also evaluates your site's SEO compliance and offers up suggestions on how to improve it.
Read the article to find out more!
Sign up for complimentary subscriptions to eWEEK, CIO Insight and Baseline magazines and receive a 360° view of today's technology arena. eWEEK gives you expert products reviews that helps you choose the best technologies. CIO Insight provides a high-level look at technologies and processes. And Baseline takes you to the front lines, with in-depth case studies. Subscribe today!
To avoid any problems with your newsletter delivery, please add newsletters@response.webbuyersguide.com to your addressbook.
You are subscribed to this newsletter with the e-mail address dwyld.kwu.wyldside@blogger.com.
If you no longer wish to receive Web Buyer's Guide Desktops & Notebooks Product Update, unsubscribe here
Copyright © 2011 Ziff Davis Enterprise. All Rights Reserved.
Ziff Davis Enterprise, 28 East 28th Street, New York, NY 10016
Privacy Policy